There’s something magical about cookies during the holidays — and sandwiching them makes them even better! Whether you’re baking for kids, gifting neighbours, or treating yourself, festive cookie sandwiches are fun, eye-catching, and easy to make. These 23 creative ideas bring together chewy cookies, creamy fillings, and seasonal flavours that everyone will love. Each recipe is simple, affordable, and packed with holiday charm. Grab your apron — it’s time to bake happiness into every bite.
1. Classic Vanilla Buttercream Sandwich Cookies
Start simple with a timeless treat. Use sugar cookies as your base, then sandwich them with homemade vanilla buttercream. Add coloured sprinkles around the edges for a festive touch. You can bake the cookies a day ahead and assemble later. It’s affordable, quick, and a great base to build on for other flavours.
2. Peppermint Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches
Chocolate and peppermint — the ultimate holiday duo. Bake soft chocolate cookies and fill them with peppermint-flavoured buttercream. Roll the sides in crushed candy canes for sparkle and crunch. Perfect for cookie exchanges or wrapping as gifts.
3. Gingerbread Cream Cheese Sandwiches
These cookies taste like Christmas in every bite. Make spiced gingerbread rounds and fill them with sweet cream cheese frosting. The tang balances the spice perfectly. For a budget-friendly twist, use store-bought dough and make your own frosting at home.
4. Red Velvet Cookie Sandwiches
Vibrant and soft, these red velvet cookies make a bold statement. Pair them with vanilla or cream cheese frosting for contrast. Roll the edges in crushed peppermint or mini white chocolate chips for a festive finish. Ideal for gifting or dessert tables.
5. Snowflake Sugar Cookie Sandwiches
Use a snowflake cookie cutter and sandwich two cookies with vanilla or lemon frosting. Decorate the tops with white icing and edible glitter. These look elegant and double as edible ornaments for holiday parties.
6. Chocolate Peppermint Ganache Sandwiches
Make a rich ganache using chocolate and plant or dairy milk, then stir in a drop of peppermint extract. Sandwich between cocoa cookies for a smooth, indulgent bite. These stay fresh for days and make great make-ahead treats.
7. Oatmeal Cream Pie Sandwiches
Homemade oatmeal cream pies are cozy and nostalgic. Use spiced oatmeal cookies and fill them with fluffy marshmallow frosting. Great for lunchbox treats or Christmas movie nights. The chewy texture makes them irresistible.
8. Peanut Butter and Chocolate Sandwich Cookies
Rich, nutty, and chocolatey. Fill soft peanut butter cookies with creamy chocolate frosting or melted ganache. Roll the edges in chopped peanuts for extra crunch. It’s an affordable, crowd-pleasing dessert for all ages.
9. S’mores Cookie Sandwiches
Bring campfire fun indoors. Sandwich marshmallow fluff and melted chocolate between graham-style cookies. Toast the edges lightly with a kitchen torch for that authentic s’mores vibe. Perfect for cozy winter nights.
10. Lemon Snow Sandwich Cookies
Add brightness to your cookie tray with zesty lemon sandwich cookies. Use a light sugar cookie base and lemon buttercream filling. Dust with powdered sugar for a “snowy” look. The citrusy tang cuts through heavier holiday flavours beautifully.
11. Hot Cocoa Cookie Sandwiches
Inspired by everyone’s favourite winter drink. Spread marshmallow fluff between two chocolate cookies, then roll the edges in mini marshmallows. Serve them warm with actual cocoa for the full cozy experience.
12. Snickerdoodle Cream Sandwiches
Soft, cinnamon-spiced cookies paired with creamy frosting make these a family favourite. Add a dash of nutmeg to the filling for extra warmth. They’re simple to make and travel well for holiday gatherings.
13. Pistachio Cranberry Cookie Sandwiches
Festive colours and nutty flavour in one treat. Combine chopped pistachios and dried cranberries in your cookie dough, then sandwich with a vanilla filling. They look beautiful on dessert platters and taste even better.
14. Pumpkin Spice Sandwich Cookies
Pumpkin purée gives these cookies a soft, chewy texture. Fill them with cinnamon-spiced frosting for that cozy holiday feel. Perfect for fall-to-winter gatherings and quick to whip up using canned pumpkin.
15. Chocolate Hazelnut Spread Sandwiches
Simple and decadent. Spread chocolate hazelnut cream between two soft cookies. Add a sprinkle of sea salt on top to balance the sweetness. These pair beautifully with coffee or hot chocolate.
16. Coconut Cream Sandwich Cookies
Mix coconut flakes into your cookie dough for texture, then fill with coconut cream frosting. Roll the edges in more coconut for a snowy effect. They’re light, aromatic, and make a refreshing twist on holiday sweets.
17. Brownie Sandwich Cookies
If you love chocolate, this one’s for you. Bake brownie-style cookies, then sandwich with rich chocolate frosting. The chewy texture and fudgy flavour make them a guaranteed hit with kids and adults.
18. Maple Pecan Cookie Sandwiches
Warm and nutty, these cookies taste like holiday mornings. Combine maple syrup and pecans in your cookie dough, then fill with vanilla frosting. A drizzle of maple glaze adds extra sweetness without extra effort.
19. Red and Green Sprinkle Sandwich Cookies
A simple recipe that’s all about fun. Use classic sugar cookies and buttercream, then roll the sides in red and green sprinkles. Kids will love helping assemble these — a perfect family baking project.
20. Chocolate Orange Cookie Sandwiches
Chocolate and orange make a festive pairing. Add orange zest to both your dough and filling for bright, aromatic flavour. It’s elegant enough for adults but sweet enough for kids to enjoy too.
21. Candy Cane Sandwich Cookies
A holiday showstopper. Sandwich peppermint frosting between chocolate cookies, then roll the sides in crushed candy canes. They’re crunchy, colourful, and full of festive cheer. Package them in clear bags for gifting.
22. Salted Caramel Cookie Sandwiches
For those who love sweet and salty flavours. Spoon caramel between buttery cookies, press gently, and sprinkle with flaky sea salt. Let them cool before serving for that chewy, rich texture.
23. Chocolate Mint Cookie Sandwiches
A classic flavour combo that never fails. Use cocoa cookies with mint-flavoured frosting. For a fun touch, tint the filling light green. These look great on cookie platters and taste like minty brownies.
Conclusion
Cookie sandwiches are the kind of holiday treat that bring smiles to every table. With these 23 fun and festive ideas, you can mix, match, and decorate to fit any occasion. Whether you love minty, nutty, fruity, or chocolatey flavours, there’s a cookie sandwich here for you. Bake them with family, share them as gifts, or enjoy them by the fire — because every bite should taste like the holidays.
Hannah Collins is a passionate home cook and food storyteller who believes every recipe tells a little love story. At TastyWriter, she shares simple, delicious recipes made for real kitchens and busy days — from cozy comfort dishes to creative new favorites. When she’s not cooking, you’ll find her photographing food, testing family recipes, or sipping tea while dreaming up her next tasty idea.
Leave a Reply